|
As Congress prepares once again to debate whether and how to add a prescription
drug benefit to Medicare, the nature of the debate has changed. Many
Republicans, including President Bush, also want to revamp the entire Medicare
program, beloved by the 41 million people for whom it provides health insurance.
They justify totally restructuring a program that works for so many individuals
and their families because they claim Medicare hasn't kept up with the times in
terms of the health coverage it provides. One of the statements frequently
heard, and accepted as gospel by those who don't know, is that Medicare doesn't
cover preventive benefits. The statement, like so many others made during this
debate, is not true.
In fact, Medicare now includes many preventive benefits
including:
-
Flu, pneumonia, and Hepatitis B vaccines
-
Annual mammograms for women age 40 and over,
with no Part B deductible;
-
A pap test every two years, and more
frequently for those at high risk for cervical cancer; again
with no Part B deductible;
-
Colon cancer screening tests, including
colonoscopy;
-
Bone mass measurement procedures for
individuals at risk;
-
Prostate cancer screening;
-
Diabetes screening tests;
-
Diabetes management training;
-
Medical nutrition therapy for those with
diabetes or kidney disease;
-
Glaucoma screening for people at risk,
including those with diabetes.
Yes, the list of preventive benefits can be improved.
Medicare does not pay for an annual physical exam or routine vision or dental
care. But the program doesn't need to be thrown out just because those services
were excluded from coverage in 1965. As with the preventive benefits listed
above, Congress can amend the Medicare statute to make annual physicals and
other routine exams available to all beneficiaries as part of the existing
program. In fact, many of these preventive benefits have been added by Congress
in just the last few years.
Congress could also, if it so chooses, decide to reduce or
eliminate co-payments or deductibles for preventive care, again without totally
revising the Medicare program. In fact, Senator Jay Rockefeller from West
Virginia and Congressman Pete Stark from California have proposed legislation
that would do just that - reform the existing Medicare program by adding
preventive services and eliminating beneficiary cost sharing for all
beneficiaries. Their reform proposal truly addresses the needs of those older
people and people with disabilities who rely on Medicare.
To say that Medicare does not cover preventive services is to
mislead the American public - and to ignore the work done by Congress over the
past decade to improve the Medicare program. To justify destroying Medicare, an
American success story, on the grounds that it is irreparable and does not cover
services it does cover or could cover, is dishonest. Congress should continue
efforts to build Medicare, rather than unnecessarily tearing it apart. |